NERD!
I also took this approach when looking for audiobooks that interested me. My motivation was to just find good books, not read all the winners, but your system seems like a good way to try a variety. You might also consult the
Nebula Award for Best Novel list. I *highly* recommend
Speed of Dark,
Flowers for Algernon, and Arthur C. Clark's Rama series. The
Red Mars series is interesting and realistic, though I've only read the first book. There's also this book called
Ender's Game that I've heard is pretty ok.
I didn't really get
To say nothing of the dog,
American Gods, or
Paladin of Souls, and I stalled in
Hyperion.
I need to read more Vonnegut and Asimov; I may join you in your Hugo quest.